You are not connected. Please login or register

VOTE - Ottawa Senators Top Prospects: #1 (2015)

Go to page : Previous  1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7  Next

Who is Ottawa's female parental unit diddling top prospect (under 25 NHL GP)?

9% 9% [ 1 ]
0% 0% [ 0 ]
0% 0% [ 0 ]
27% 27% [ 3 ]
64% 64% [ 7 ]
0% 0% [ 0 ]
0% 0% [ 0 ]
0% 0% [ 0 ]
0% 0% [ 0 ]
0% 0% [ 0 ]
0% 0% [ 0 ]
0% 0% [ 0 ]
0% 0% [ 0 ]
0% 0% [ 0 ]
0% 0% [ 0 ]
Total Votes : 11

Go down  Message [Page 5 of 7]

wprager


Administrator
Administrator
DefenceWinsChampionships wrote:Paul, Puempel and Prince are our three most NHL ready prospects. That is undisputable.

Define "NHL ready". Puempel has shown what he can do at the NHL level in the heat of a playoff race. Too bad he got injured because he was playing pretty well, IMO. Prince payed well, too but what about when the adrenaline of playing in your first NHL game wears off? I don't know if he's any more ready than, say, Claesson, because Claesson's role would be as a stay-at-home 3rd pairing defenseman. Paul hasn't played a minute of pro. No idea how "NHL ready" he is, regardless of definition.

spader


All-Star
All-Star
DefenceWinsChampionships wrote:Paul, Puempel and Prince are our three most NHL ready prospects. That is undisputable.

One of them is disputable. When you haven't played a single pro-game (and aren't named McDavid), your NHL readiness is up for debate.

I agree that Prince and Pumps are the closest though.

wprager


Administrator
Administrator
Ev wrote:
wprager wrote:You sound surprised.

very. Don't see any scenario where he should be over Puempel at the moment. And I would put White and Chabot over him personally.

Puempel has shown that he could probably step in and replace Condra's lost production. Paul has higher upside. I can easily see how someone would rank him above Puempel in this poll.

As for Paul vs. your boy Colin White, don't forget that this is the guy Murray insisted on when trading Spezza. And since then he had a great season in the OHL and was asked to play at the WJC. I'd say he's ranked higher than White and Chabot, for sure.

SensHulk

avatar
All-Star
All-Star
My reasoning is the nick Paul seemingly has the most buzz around him as far as sens prospects go and with good reason. Pierre Dorion raved about him and McCormick more Than any other prospect at the dev camp. Furthermore, his stock has risen a lot since he got traded. He started turning heads at the world jr camp as well. Quite simply he's rising fast and he's gonna be in the ahl challenging for a call up which means he's not too far either. He's my vote for sure.

Puemps would be second just cuz he's been around for so long and honestly is starting to feel less like a prospect and more like a project (in a good way). He hasn't taken anyone by storm but his confidence is finally starting kick in and he's taking charge .

NEELY


Mod
Mod
Ev wrote:
wprager wrote:You sound surprised.

very. Don't see any scenario where he should be over Puempel at the moment. And I would put White and Chabot over him personally.

There's the problem, you give Paul very little credit. I on the other hand think he's a potential top 6 forward and worst case he's going to be a very solid 3rd line center. To me the fact there is little bust potential is big rating prospects. I also think his size could be a big factor as well.

NEELY


Mod
Mod
DefenceWinsChampionships wrote:Paul, Puempel and Prince are our three most NHL ready prospects. That is undisputable.

Wikstrand isn't far off by all accounts.

McCormick should be getting a little more love as a prospect as well but he's a 4th line NHLer through and through. Not sexy but important.

Ev

avatar
Franchise Player
Franchise Player
NEELY wrote:
Ev wrote:
wprager wrote:You sound surprised.

very. Don't see any scenario where he should be over Puempel at the moment. And I would put White and Chabot over him personally.

There's the problem, you give Paul very little credit.  I on the other hand think he's a potential top 6 forward and worst case he's going to be a very solid 3rd line center.  To me the fact there is little bust potential is big rating prospects.  I also think his size could be a big factor as well.

I'm not not giving him credit. He's one of my favorite prospects. I just think he is for sure under Puempel at this point due to offensive upside.

Nick Paul will make the NHL but at this point his upside is in the air. I think he will be like Sean couturier.

Ev

avatar
Franchise Player
Franchise Player
wprager wrote:
Ev wrote:
wprager wrote:You sound surprised.

very. Don't see any scenario where he should be over Puempel at the moment. And I would put White and Chabot over him personally.

Puempel has shown that he could probably step in and replace Condra's lost production.  Paul has higher upside.  I can easily see how someone would rank him above Puempel in this poll.

As for Paul vs. your boy Colin White, don't forget that this is the guy Murray insisted on when trading Spezza.  And since then he had a great season in the OHL and was asked to play at the WJC.  I'd say he's ranked higher than White and Chabot, for sure.  

Paul does nto have higher upside than Puempel, offensively. Peumepel is a pure goal scorer with a much better shot and is a better skater right now.

Murray wants Puempel in the NHL badly. That's how much they like him. To me the results of this poll are all about the shiny new toy syndrome. Puempel has paid his dues, developed, and has proven he can play in the NHL unlike any guy on this list.

You saying he insisted on Paul in the trade is news to me and probably made up on your part. The scouts would be the ones who ask for players . Murray probably had no idea who he was lol.

As for white. Continue to underrate him. I would wager he would be above Pail I'd the org was polled today but its irrelevant, I think both will make it and be third liners at the worst

Ev

avatar
Franchise Player
Franchise Player
Michallica wrote:My reasoning is the nick Paul seemingly has the most buzz around him as far as sens prospects go and with good reason. Pierre Dorion raved about him and McCormick more Than any other prospect at the dev camp. Furthermore, his stock has risen a lot since he got traded. He started turning heads at the world jr camp as well. Quite simply he's rising fast and he's gonna be in the ahl challenging for a call up which means he's not too far either. He's my vote for sure.

Puemps would be second just cuz he's been around for so long and honestly is starting to feel less like a prospect and more like a project (in a good way). He hasn't taken anyone by storm but his confidence is finally starting kick in and he's taking charge .

Puemeple was on another level than the other forwards at camp but did not play in the  scrimmages. He has less hype because he's been around for a while but he's done everything asked and is the closest NHL player with the highest offensive upside among our prospects IMO

wprager

avatar
Administrator
Administrator
First, regarding them specifically asking for Paul, I didn't make it up, I read it. Somewhere. Possibly even here.

Regarding White, I am not under-valuing him; I'm simply waiting to see how he does at the pro level, playing 80 games per season.

As for Paul vs. Puempel, you have to keep in mind that Paul is a very late bloomer w.r.t. his size. It is very difficult to adjust to an extra half a foot in height and probably an extra 40 lbs in weight. However as an 18 year old (a later 18 year old) he starting putting up points at a higher than PPG pace in the OHL. He's late, yes, but there is a reason, and the trajectory is pretty good.

He is also said to have above average IQ, and not the best skater. Sound like someone else we know. His skating is likely a product of his rapid, late growth, and he will continue to improve.

I like Puempel a lot, but I still see hm as a pretty decent 3rd liner, whereas Paul has the size that could help him get into the top-six and also get PP time.


_________________
Hey, I don't have all the answers. In life, to be honest, I've failed as much as I have succeeded. But I love my wife. I love my life. And I wish you my kind of success.
- Dicky Fox

Ev

avatar
Franchise Player
Franchise Player
wprager wrote:First, regarding them specifically asking for Paul, I didn't make it up, I read it.  Somewhere.  Possibly even here.

Regarding White, I am not under-valuing him; I'm simply waiting to see how he does at the pro level, playing 80 games per season.  

As for Paul vs. Puempel, you have to keep in mind that Paul is a very late bloomer w.r.t. his size.  It is very difficult to adjust to an extra half a foot in height and probably an extra 40 lbs in weight.  However as an 18 year old (a later 18 year old) he starting putting up points at a higher than PPG pace in the OHL.  He's late, yes, but there is a reason, and the trajectory is pretty good.

He is also said to have above average IQ, and not the best skater.  Sound like someone else we know.  His skating is likely a product of his rapid, late growth, and he will continue to improve.  

I like Puempel a lot, but I still see hm as a pretty decent 3rd liner, whereas Paul has the size that could help him get into the top-six and also get PP time.

Puempel has size. His upside is not a third liner. He is a goal scorer and was drafted to score goals. Saying all he will do is replace Condra is pretty funny. Puempel has developed his game and is now an all around winger with edge and offense

As for white and waiting for him to play 80 games at the pro level...apparently you're not doing the same for Paul. Pretty hypocritical.


Anyways I think people are wrong here but not much I can do about that.

spader

avatar
All-Star
All-Star
Ev wrote:
NEELY wrote:
Ev wrote:
wprager wrote:You sound surprised.

very. Don't see any scenario where he should be over Puempel at the moment. And I would put White and Chabot over him personally.

There's the problem, you give Paul very little credit.  I on the other hand think he's a potential top 6 forward and worst case he's going to be a very solid 3rd line center.  To me the fact there is little bust potential is big rating prospects.  I also think his size could be a big factor as well.

I'm not not giving him credit. He's one of my favorite prospects. I just think he is for sure under Puempel at this point due to offensive upside.

Nick Paul will make the NHL but at this point his upside is in the air. I think he will be like Sean couturier.

Is he even defined yet? I feel like he's still figuring it out.

spader

avatar
All-Star
All-Star
FWIW I can remember a conversation on here about Paul being the centrepiece in the return.

NEELY


Mod
Mod
Ev wrote:
NEELY wrote:
Ev wrote:
wprager wrote:You sound surprised.

very. Don't see any scenario where he should be over Puempel at the moment. And I would put White and Chabot over him personally.

There's the problem, you give Paul very little credit.  I on the other hand think he's a potential top 6 forward and worst case he's going to be a very solid 3rd line center.  To me the fact there is little bust potential is big rating prospects.  I also think his size could be a big factor as well.

I'm not not giving him credit. He's one of my favorite prospects. I just think he is for sure under Puempel at this point due to offensive upside.

Nick Paul will make the NHL but at this point his upside is in the air. I think he will be like Sean couturier.

I'll take a Courturier over a Peumpel too. This isn't to say I dislike Puempel, though but I value players who are well rounded and can grow into an offensive role.

NEELY


Mod
Mod
I do like the Paul/Couturier comparison though.

I do think Paul has some offensive upside and a lot of it, not to the same extent as Puempel pretty close, probably more of a play maker than Puempel and in all honesty he could be Puempel's center for a long time if things go well.

LeCaptain

avatar
All-Star
All-Star
wprager wrote:
Ev wrote:
wprager wrote:You sound surprised.

very. Don't see any scenario where he should be over Puempel at the moment. And I would put White and Chabot over him personally.

Puempel has shown that he could probably step in and replace Condra's lost production.  Paul has higher upside.  I can easily see how someone would rank him above Puempel in this poll.

As for Paul vs. your boy Colin White, don't forget that this is the guy Murray insisted on when trading Spezza.  And since then he had a great season in the OHL and was asked to play at the WJC.  I'd say he's ranked higher than White and Chabot, for sure.  

Very debatable.

At the same age, Puempel had 35 goals in 51 games, Paul had 37 in 58.
Just by viewing I would say Puempel's offensive hockey sense is way higher.
I think Puempel will have a monster rookie season in Ottawa. But it will depend on Hoffman's contract.

Also Chabot's scouting reports suggests he's a future top pairing Defenseman. That has way more value than a top 6 forward.

PTFlea

avatar
Co-Founder
Co-Founder
Someday we'll see a Paul, white, Lazar line I think. So much to like with these type of players and so much safer than some other prospects.

Flo The Action

avatar
All-Star
All-Star
LeCaptain wrote:
wprager wrote:
Ev wrote:
wprager wrote:You sound surprised.

very. Don't see any scenario where he should be over Puempel at the moment. And I would put White and Chabot over him personally.

Puempel has shown that he could probably step in and replace Condra's lost production.  Paul has higher upside.  I can easily see how someone would rank him above Puempel in this poll.

As for Paul vs. your boy Colin White, don't forget that this is the guy Murray insisted on when trading Spezza.  And since then he had a great season in the OHL and was asked to play at the WJC.  I'd say he's ranked higher than White and Chabot, for sure.  

Very debatable.

At the same age, Puempel had 35 goals in 51 games, Paul had 37 in 58.
Just by viewing I would say Puempel's offensive hockey sense is way higher.
I think Puempel will have a monster rookie season in Ottawa. But it will depend on Hoffman's contract.

Also Chabot's scouting reports suggests he's a future top pairing Defenseman. That has way more value than a top 6 forward.

That's one report. I've also seen report where he is top 4. It's hard to really know what he will become. Especially thatDman take a little younger and it's been said that he still has a lot of development to do.
So no, I would not go outright and say he's a top pairing Dman just yet.

Sponsored content


Back to top  Message [Page 5 of 7]

Go to page : Previous  1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7  Next

Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum