PublicationsI agree. Neil isn't just an enforcer, he makes it very hard to play against as he also does deliver some really good hits and is good on a fourth line role. For now. The minute he can't keep up with the pace is when he'll be done.tim1_2 wrote:DefenceWinsChampionships wrote:Flo The Action wrote:Yeah personally I'd rather have Neil on the 4th than Boro on the blue line. At this point I'd rather have a forward deliver the hard checks than a dman. Less dangerous in terms of puck possessiontim1_2 wrote:DefenceWinsChampionships wrote:Nice to see Neil throw his body around but is his role ever unnecessary considering the pace of the game and size of the players now.
I get so sick of this dumb discussion every year. Neil knocked out on of their defensemen early in the game with a huge hit, and threw a few more good checks that get players (especially young defenders like Zaitsev) thinking twice. On top of that, he had a few decent scoring chances, and his line had a couple of the only sequences of actual pressure in the offensive zone. Neil has adapted his game over the years and is still quite valuable as a 4th liner. And you know that if anyone starts pushing around Karlsson or Turris or Stone or whoever that Neil will step the Diddle up and deal with it immediately. The only other guy that might do that is Boro, and his position on the blue line is tenuous at best.
I agree. Neil has a role and he plays it well. The point I am making is that his role is becoming less and less significant as fighting league-wide is on the decline. Yes he is there to protect the players on the team and make the opposing players react when they see him coming. But couldn't a Buddy Robinson do that? Max McCormick? Guys who can kill penalties and bring something else to the table... I am not arguing that Neil isn't good at doing his job. I am arguing the fact that the role of an enforcer is quickly disappearing.
And I'm saying that his role extends beyond the typical "enforcer" role. Toronto had to play the game with 5 D because of a big hit he delivered early on. And I'm not saying that he should be going around looking to injure opponents, but that kind of sustained physical play has more effects than just the odd injury. Plus, the 4th line actually generated some scoring opportunities and o-zone pressure.
GDT - Game #1: Leafs @ Sens, Oct 12, 2016, 7pm
Flo The Action- All-Star
- Number of posts : 13112
Registration date : 2008-12-18
- Post n°91
Re: GDT - Game #1: Leafs @ Sens, Oct 12, 2016, 7pm
by Flo The Action on Thu Oct 13, 2016 5:06 pm
Flo The Action- All-Star
- Number of posts : 13112
Registration date : 2008-12-18
- Post n°92
Re: GDT - Game #1: Leafs @ Sens, Oct 12, 2016, 7pm
by Flo The Action on Thu Oct 13, 2016 5:08 pm
I tend to agree with this view. I'd prefer smith on the third.Hoff-Machine wrote:brassard/ryan don't need smith on their line.....pageau does. I don't know if that logic registers with everyone here but it makes a ton of sense to me. Smith isn't defining that line, I don't get the opposition to putting him back with Pageau.
Flo The Action- All-Star
- Number of posts : 13112
Registration date : 2008-12-18
- Post n°93
Re: GDT - Game #1: Leafs @ Sens, Oct 12, 2016, 7pm
by Flo The Action on Thu Oct 13, 2016 5:10 pm
Still would look better on the fourth line.PTFlea wrote:https://twitter.com/SunDoniB/status/786624228510490624?ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw
Don Brennan
@SunDoniB
Boucher says Karlsson and Tom Pyatt were #sens best players defensively 1 on 1 vs Leafs
Flo The Action- All-Star
- Number of posts : 13112
Age : 41
Location : montreal
Favorite Team : Ottawa
Registration date : 2008-12-18
- Post n°94
Re: GDT - Game #1: Leafs @ Sens, Oct 12, 2016, 7pm
by Flo The Action on Sun Oct 16, 2016 4:13 pm
Man Matthews with such a disinterested smug look on his face on his fourth goal. That's a face you can learn to hate. For christs sake, celebrate a little! The opposite of lazar.
spader- All-Star
- Number of posts : 10065
Age : 37
Location : Toronto
Favorite Team : Ottawa
Registration date : 2009-07-09
Flo The Action wrote:I tend to agree with this view. I'd prefer smith on the third.Hoff-Machine wrote:brassard/ryan don't need smith on their line.....pageau does. I don't know if that logic registers with everyone here but it makes a ton of sense to me. Smith isn't defining that line, I don't get the opposition to putting him back with Pageau.
Whatever wins games.
PTFlea- Co-Founder
- Number of posts : 54403
Favorite Team : Ottawa
Registration date : 2008-07-31
I think dzingel could do what smith is doing on the 2nd line, but smithhas been good imo
wprager- Administrator
- Number of posts : 47936
Age : 55
Location : Kanata
Favorite Team : Ottawa
Registration date : 2008-08-05
They tried Dzingel in the top-six an he promptly went -3 in the first half of the game. That was in pre-season and I'm not sure if it was a home or away game (line matching). He's fine on the 3rd line.
_________________
Hey, I don't have all the answers. In life, to be honest, I've failed as much as I have succeeded. But I love my wife. I love my life. And I wish you my kind of success.
- Dicky Fox
PTFlea- Co-Founder
- Number of posts : 54403
Favorite Team : Ottawa
Registration date : 2008-07-31
wprager wrote:They tried Dzingel in the top-six an he promptly went -3 in the first half of the game. That was in pre-season and I'm not sure if it was a home or away game (line matching). He's fine on the 3rd line.
Meh, means nothing. He played a chunk of games in the top six last year and lacked only the finish that comes with games. I think they'll try him there soon so they can start balancing the offense around by moving Smith - no offense to the newfound scoring champ Tom Pyatt. Or they could just leave him at 3C and hope they mesh as well as Smith did with Pageau, which I could see. He's fast, he's feisty, they might work well together.
wprager- Administrator
- Number of posts : 47936
Age : 55
Location : Kanata
Favorite Team : Ottawa
Registration date : 2008-08-05
I like Dzingel, but he is not a top-six player, come on. He's probably good for 10-12 goals which is 3rd line.
_________________
Hey, I don't have all the answers. In life, to be honest, I've failed as much as I have succeeded. But I love my wife. I love my life. And I wish you my kind of success.
- Dicky Fox
DefenceWinsChampionships- Veteran
- Number of posts : 1948
Age : 87
Location : Ottawa
Favorite Team : Ottawa
Registration date : 2011-05-23
- Post n°100
Re: GDT - Game #1: Leafs @ Sens, Oct 12, 2016, 7pm
by DefenceWinsChampionships on Mon Oct 17, 2016 2:46 pm
PTFlea wrote:wprager wrote:They tried Dzingel in the top-six an he promptly went -3 in the first half of the game. That was in pre-season and I'm not sure if it was a home or away game (line matching). He's fine on the 3rd line.
Meh, means nothing. He played a chunk of games in the top six last year and lacked only the finish that comes with games. I think they'll try him there soon so they can start balancing the offense around by moving Smith - no offense to the newfound scoring champ Tom Pyatt. Or they could just leave him at 3C and hope they mesh as well as Smith did with Pageau, which I could see. He's fast, he's feisty, they might work well together.
Dzingel-Pageau-Lazar/Puempel.... Could be worse
Varone/Pyatt-Kelly-Neil
Flo The Action- All-Star
- Number of posts : 13112
Age : 41
Location : montreal
Favorite Team : Ottawa
Registration date : 2008-12-18
- Post n°101
Re: GDT - Game #1: Leafs @ Sens, Oct 12, 2016, 7pm
by Flo The Action on Mon Oct 17, 2016 3:27 pm
I'd prefere that.DefenceWinsChampionships wrote:PTFlea wrote:wprager wrote:They tried Dzingel in the top-six an he promptly went -3 in the first half of the game. That was in pre-season and I'm not sure if it was a home or away game (line matching). He's fine on the 3rd line.
Meh, means nothing. He played a chunk of games in the top six last year and lacked only the finish that comes with games. I think they'll try him there soon so they can start balancing the offense around by moving Smith - no offense to the newfound scoring champ Tom Pyatt. Or they could just leave him at 3C and hope they mesh as well as Smith did with Pageau, which I could see. He's fast, he's feisty, they might work well together.
Dzingel-Pageau-Lazar/Puempel.... Could be worse
Varone/Pyatt-Kelly-Neil
PTFlea- Co-Founder
- Number of posts : 54403
Favorite Team : Ottawa
Registration date : 2008-07-31
Flo The Action wrote:I'd prefere that.DefenceWinsChampionships wrote:PTFlea wrote:wprager wrote:They tried Dzingel in the top-six an he promptly went -3 in the first half of the game. That was in pre-season and I'm not sure if it was a home or away game (line matching). He's fine on the 3rd line.
Meh, means nothing. He played a chunk of games in the top six last year and lacked only the finish that comes with games. I think they'll try him there soon so they can start balancing the offense around by moving Smith - no offense to the newfound scoring champ Tom Pyatt. Or they could just leave him at 3C and hope they mesh as well as Smith did with Pageau, which I could see. He's fast, he's feisty, they might work well together.
Dzingel-Pageau-Lazar/Puempel.... Could be worse
Varone/Pyatt-Kelly-Neil
lol, what's this Varone/Pyatt? Do you really think Pyatt is ever coming out of this lineup with Boucher in charge? Not only does he love him, but the dude scored a game-tying goal in Game 2.
Flo The Action- All-Star
- Number of posts : 13112
Age : 41
Location : montreal
Favorite Team : Ottawa
Registration date : 2008-12-18
- Post n°103
Re: GDT - Game #1: Leafs @ Sens, Oct 12, 2016, 7pm
by Flo The Action on Mon Oct 17, 2016 5:48 pm
Not out of the lineup but down to the fourth line.PTFlea wrote:Flo The Action wrote:I'd prefere that.DefenceWinsChampionships wrote:PTFlea wrote:wprager wrote:They tried Dzingel in the top-six an he promptly went -3 in the first half of the game. That was in pre-season and I'm not sure if it was a home or away game (line matching). He's fine on the 3rd line.
Meh, means nothing. He played a chunk of games in the top six last year and lacked only the finish that comes with games. I think they'll try him there soon so they can start balancing the offense around by moving Smith - no offense to the newfound scoring champ Tom Pyatt. Or they could just leave him at 3C and hope they mesh as well as Smith did with Pageau, which I could see. He's fast, he's feisty, they might work well together.
Dzingel-Pageau-Lazar/Puempel.... Could be worse
Varone/Pyatt-Kelly-Neil
lol, what's this Varone/Pyatt? Do you really think Pyatt is ever coming out of this lineup with Boucher in charge? Not only does he love him, but the dude scored a game-tying goal in Game 2.